The Book of Job and the Role of Uncertainty in Religion and Law
This Faculty Working Paper has been updated and posted within the Georgetown Law Faculty Lectures and Appearances series in the Scholarly Commons. It is currently available at http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/fac_lectures/8/
Abstract
The Book of Job depicts the radical uncertainty that results when people try to comprehend God. Job has had an extraordinary influence on philosophy and literature, and its message on the limits of human knowledge has even been echoed in the words of great scientists. Surprisingly, however, it has had little influence on the rhetoric or approach of lawyers and judges. The legal profession, which confronts uncertain outcomes daily, has reduced uncertainty to a mundane calculation of odds, while ignoring the more fundamental idea of the unknown because that idea would paralyze legal work.